When the boy's moon is in Magha and the girl's in Shravana, the four birth-star kootas — tara, yoni, gana and nadi — contribute 4.5 of their 21 points. The full 36-guna score depends on which pada (quarter) each moon occupies: across all sixteen pada combinations it ranges from 5.5 to 6.5 out of 36.
Every pada combination of this pairing lands in the “Needs a careful look” band of the classical reading. Below is what each koota actually contributes — computed, not copied from a compatibility chart.
The birth-star kootas (fixed for this pair)
- Tara (1.5/3): counted from each birth star to the other; this pair scores 1.5 points.
- Yoni (2/4): neutral yoni animals (Rat and Monkey) — 2 of 4 points.
- Gana (1/6): Magha is Rakshasa (intense, strong-willed); Shravana is Deva (gentle, giving). That scores 1 of 6.
- Nadi (0/8 — dosha, unless cancelled): both stars are Antya nadi. This is the heaviest single loss in the system — and the one fear-sellers lean on. The classical cancellation is checked per pada in the table below; for this pair no pada combination cancels it, so a pandit would weigh the whole chart instead.
Bhakoot: watch the pada
Because Magha and Shravana each span sign boundaries by pada, bhakoot dosha (0/7) arises for pada combinations 1–1, 1–2, 1–3, 1–4, 2–1, 2–2, 2–3, 2–4, 3–1, 3–2, 3–3, 3–4, 4–1, 4–2, 4–3, 4–4. This is exactly why a score without pada is a guess.
Every pada combination, scored
Boy pada – girl pada, the moon signs they imply, and the complete 36-guna total (all eight kootas, cancellations applied):
| Padas (B–G) | Boy moon | Girl moon | Score /36 | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1–1 | Simha (Leo) | Makara (Capricorn) | 5.5 | nadi dosha, bhakoot dosha |
| 1–2 | Simha (Leo) | Makara (Capricorn) | 6.5 | nadi dosha, bhakoot dosha |
| 1–3 | Simha (Leo) | Makara (Capricorn) | 6.5 | nadi dosha, bhakoot dosha |
| 1–4 | Simha (Leo) | Makara (Capricorn) | 6.5 | nadi dosha, bhakoot dosha |
| 2–1 | Simha (Leo) | Makara (Capricorn) | 5.5 | nadi dosha, bhakoot dosha |
| 2–2 | Simha (Leo) | Makara (Capricorn) | 6.5 | nadi dosha, bhakoot dosha |
| 2–3 | Simha (Leo) | Makara (Capricorn) | 6.5 | nadi dosha, bhakoot dosha |
| 2–4 | Simha (Leo) | Makara (Capricorn) | 6.5 | nadi dosha, bhakoot dosha |
| 3–1 | Simha (Leo) | Makara (Capricorn) | 5.5 | nadi dosha, bhakoot dosha |
| 3–2 | Simha (Leo) | Makara (Capricorn) | 6.5 | nadi dosha, bhakoot dosha |
| 3–3 | Simha (Leo) | Makara (Capricorn) | 6.5 | nadi dosha, bhakoot dosha |
| 3–4 | Simha (Leo) | Makara (Capricorn) | 6.5 | nadi dosha, bhakoot dosha |
| 4–1 | Simha (Leo) | Makara (Capricorn) | 5.5 | nadi dosha, bhakoot dosha |
| 4–2 | Simha (Leo) | Makara (Capricorn) | 6.5 | nadi dosha, bhakoot dosha |
| 4–3 | Simha (Leo) | Makara (Capricorn) | 6.5 | nadi dosha, bhakoot dosha |
| 4–4 | Simha (Leo) | Makara (Capricorn) | 6.5 | nadi dosha, bhakoot dosha |
The honest read
If an online calculator gave you one flat number for Magha–Shravana, it guessed your padas — or ignored them. The spread above (5.5 to 6.5) is the truth of this pairing. And even the right number is the beginning of matching, not the end: dasha timing, the seventh house of both charts, and manglik for both partners sit outside the guna count entirely. Anyone who turns a low number into a remedy bill skipped all of that on purpose.
Related: Shravana boy – Magha girl (reverse) · Magha compatibility with all 27 nakshatras · Shravana compatibility · what a score of 5 means
This page scores the moon stars. Your real charts say more.
Names and birth stars are the shortcut. The honest answer comes from two fully computed charts — exact birth time and place, every koota, manglik for both partners, and the cancellations shown instead of hidden. Free, in one minute.
No fear-selling, no gemstone upsells — ever, by written policy.