When the boy's moon is in Magha and the girl's in Vishakha, the four birth-star kootas — tara, yoni, gana and nadi — contribute 9.5 of their 21 points. The full 36-guna score depends on which pada (quarter) each moon occupies: across all sixteen pada combinations it ranges from 17.5 to 21.5 out of 36.
Depending on pada, this pairing lands anywhere from “Needs a careful look” to “Acceptable” on the classical bands. Below is what each koota actually contributes — computed, not copied from a compatibility chart.
The birth-star kootas (fixed for this pair)
- Tara (1.5/3): counted from each birth star to the other; this pair scores 1.5 points.
- Yoni (2/4): neutral yoni animals (Rat and Tiger) — 2 of 4 points.
- Gana (6/6): Magha is Rakshasa (intense, strong-willed); Vishakha is Rakshasa (intense, strong-willed). That scores 6 of 6.
- Nadi (0/8 — dosha, unless cancelled): both stars are Antya nadi. This is the heaviest single loss in the system — and the one fear-sellers lean on. The classical cancellation is checked per pada in the table below; for this pair no pada combination cancels it, so a pandit would weigh the whole chart instead.
Every pada combination, scored
Boy pada – girl pada, the moon signs they imply, and the complete 36-guna total (all eight kootas, cancellations applied):
| Padas (B–G) | Boy moon | Girl moon | Score /36 | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1–1 | Simha (Leo) | Tula (Libra) | 17.5 | nadi dosha |
| 1–2 | Simha (Leo) | Tula (Libra) | 17.5 | nadi dosha |
| 1–3 | Simha (Leo) | Tula (Libra) | 17.5 | nadi dosha |
| 1–4 | Simha (Leo) | Vrishchika (Scorpio) | 21.5 | nadi dosha |
| 2–1 | Simha (Leo) | Tula (Libra) | 17.5 | nadi dosha |
| 2–2 | Simha (Leo) | Tula (Libra) | 17.5 | nadi dosha |
| 2–3 | Simha (Leo) | Tula (Libra) | 17.5 | nadi dosha |
| 2–4 | Simha (Leo) | Vrishchika (Scorpio) | 21.5 | nadi dosha |
| 3–1 | Simha (Leo) | Tula (Libra) | 17.5 | nadi dosha |
| 3–2 | Simha (Leo) | Tula (Libra) | 17.5 | nadi dosha |
| 3–3 | Simha (Leo) | Tula (Libra) | 17.5 | nadi dosha |
| 3–4 | Simha (Leo) | Vrishchika (Scorpio) | 21.5 | nadi dosha |
| 4–1 | Simha (Leo) | Tula (Libra) | 17.5 | nadi dosha |
| 4–2 | Simha (Leo) | Tula (Libra) | 17.5 | nadi dosha |
| 4–3 | Simha (Leo) | Tula (Libra) | 17.5 | nadi dosha |
| 4–4 | Simha (Leo) | Vrishchika (Scorpio) | 21.5 | nadi dosha |
The honest read
If an online calculator gave you one flat number for Magha–Vishakha, it guessed your padas — or ignored them. The spread above (17.5 to 21.5) is the truth of this pairing. And even the right number is the beginning of matching, not the end: dasha timing, the seventh house of both charts, and manglik for both partners sit outside the guna count entirely. Anyone who turns a low number into a remedy bill skipped all of that on purpose.
Related: Vishakha boy – Magha girl (reverse) · Magha compatibility with all 27 nakshatras · Vishakha compatibility · what a score of 17 means
This page scores the moon stars. Your real charts say more.
Names and birth stars are the shortcut. The honest answer comes from two fully computed charts — exact birth time and place, every koota, manglik for both partners, and the cancellations shown instead of hidden. Free, in one minute.
No fear-selling, no gemstone upsells — ever, by written policy.